A rod of length l and negligible mass is suspended at its two ends by two wires of steel (wire A) and aluminium (wire B) of equal lengths (figure). The cross-sectional areas of wires A and B are 1.0 mm2 and 2.0 mm2 respectively. (YAl=70×109 N/m2 and Ysteel=200×109 N/m2)



 

a. Mass m should be suspended close to wire A to have equal stresses in both wires.
b. Mass m should be suspended close to B to have equal stresses in both wires.
c. Mass m should be suspended in the middle of the wires to have equal stresses in both wires.
d. Mass m should be suspended close to wire A to have equal strain in both wires.

The correct statements are:

1. (b, c)

2. (a, d)

3. (b, d)

4. (c, d)

(3) Hint: The stress and strain in the wires depend on Young's modulus of the wires.
Step 1: Find the stresses in the wires.
Let the mass is placed at x from end B.
Let TA and TB be the tensions in wire A and wire B respectively.
For the rotational equilibrium of the system,
                                            Τζ=0                                              (Total torque = 0)
                  TBx-TA(l-x)=0
                                   TBTA=l-xx                                                            ...(i)
Stress in wire A, =SA=TAaA
Stress in wire B, SB=TBaB
where aA and aB are cross-sectional areas of wires A and B respectively.
Step 2: Find the location of the mass for equal stresses in the wires.
According to the question, aB=2aA
Now, for equal stresses, SA=SB
                                TAaA=TBaBTBTA=aBaA=2
                                l-xx=2   lx-1=2
                                      x=l3  l-x=l-l/3=2l3
Hence, the mass m should be placed closer to B.
Step 3: Find the location of the mass for equal strain in the wires.
For equal strain,      (strain)A=(strain)B
                               (YA)SA=YBSB                 (Where YA and YB are Young's moduli)
                              YsteelTA/aA=YAlTB/aB
                               YsteelYAl=TATB×aBaA=xl-x2aAaA
                             200×10970×109=2xl-x207=2xl-x
                                     107=xl-x10l-10x=7x
                                      17x=10l x=10l17
                                          l-x=l-10l17=7l17
Hence, the mass m should be placed closer to wire A.